OSA asks DOJ-USDA to Take Hard Look at Monsanto’s Comments on Seed Concentration

OSA submitted public comments today to the Departments of Justice and Agriculture that serve as a rebuttal to comments provided by Monsanto. Thirty-eight leading food and seed companies along with nonprofits and farm associations signed on to the comments. View the press release below and read the comments here (opens PDF).


June 1, 2010


Matthew Dillon, Director of Advocacy, Organic Seed Alliance, 360-385-7192, matthew@seedalliance.org

Kristina Hubbard, Advocacy Program Specialist, Organic Seed Alliance, 406-544-8946, kristina@seedalliance.org

Organizations and Businesses Ask Departments of Justice and Agriculture to Take Hard Look at Monsanto’s Comments Regarding Health of Seed Industry 

Nearly 40 organizations and seed and food companies sent the Departments of Justice and Agriculture (DOJ-USDA) a simple reminder today: The seed industry demonstrates some of the most troubling concentration trends in agriculture and is in need of a serious examination.

The comments serve as a rebuttal to the Monsanto Company’s assertion that competition in the seed industry is alive and well.

“The rapid consolidation of the seed industry has led to less choice for farmers, especially organic and conventional growers,” says Kristina Hubbard of Organic Seed Alliance. “We are encouraged by the agencies’ efforts to investigate competition concerns as they relate to the seed industry and look forward to meaningful action.”

In addition to serving as a rebuttal to Monsanto’s comments to DOJ-USDA, the group’s letter and comments ask that the agencies broaden their investigation beyond the biotech trait disputes receiving much of the media attention. The signatories contend that farmers, seed companies and plant breeders in a variety of sectors are impacted by a host of other issues that warrant further examination, including the concentrated ownership of germplasm; increased consolidation in other crop sectors, such as sugarbeets and vegetables; and the effects patents have on facilitating market advantage for the largest firms and inhibiting important research in the private and public sector.

The letter also reminds DOJ-USDA that to return to a more competitive marketplace that serves the diverse needs of American agriculture there must be recognition and support for the contributions of public plant breeding programs. Once a competitor in the release of new varieties, the public sector has been negatively impacted by concentration in the seed industry, reliance on research funds from the largest seed firms, and the liberal usage of patents that restrict basic research.

“The seed industry has consolidated faster than most other agricultural sectors, and faster than any natural resource,” says Matthew Dillon of Organic Seed Alliance. “The Departments of Justice and Agriculture should host a workshop focused solely on seed industry concentration given the complex consequences farmers and independent seed companies are facing, and the role of this resource in food security.”

The group’s comments can be downloaded at www.seedalliance.org/Advocacy.

Download press release

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to OSA asks DOJ-USDA to Take Hard Look at Monsanto’s Comments on Seed Concentration

  1. Pingback: Competition Workshops Conclude in DC | Seed Broadcast

  2. Pingback: Congress Must Make Competition Concerns a Priority | Seed Broadcast

Comments are closed.